Why Punishments Miss the Mark

And What Works Better

Imagine this common scene in any family’s life: Annie walks into the living room and finds her son, Max, crying after having pushed his sister, Lily, in a squabble over a toy. Annie’s instinct is to discipline sternly – “Max, go to your room, no TV for you today!” – a typical reaction reflecting how many of us were raised. But then, Annie pauses, a crucial insight surfacing in her mind: “Punishment often does more harm than good.” This moment of hesitation invites us to explore why punishment might not be the best teaching tool and what other strategies could be more effective.

Why Not Punishment?

Children’s Emotional Development: A Crucial Aspect
First of all, it’s vital to understand that children like Max come into the world filled with emotions but lacking the skills to manage them. When Max lashes out, it’s not a sign of defiance but rather an expression of frustration. He’s speaking a language of action, not words, because he hasn’t yet learned how to communicate his feelings appropriately. As a comparison, punishing him for this lack of skill is like scolding a child for not knowing how to swim when they’ve never had a swimming lesson.

The Limitations of Punishment: Addressing the Surface
Secondly, we must recognize that punishments like time-outs or revoked privileges might seem to address the immediate problem, but they don’t tackle the underlying issue. If Lily takes his toy again, Max, without having learned to handle his emotions or express himself properly, is likely to react in the same way. Punishment doesn’t give him the tools for better choices; it only suppresses the symptoms, leaving the root cause untreated.

The Unintended Consequences: Internalizing Negative Self-Perceptions
Moreover, there’s the issue of how constant punishment affects a child’s self-perception. Children crave approval from their parents. When they are repeatedly punished, they might begin to internalize a negative view of themselves, asking, “Am I always bad?” This self-doubt can lead to a harmful self-fulfilling prophecy, where the child, like Max, might start to believe and act out the ‘bad kid’ label. 

Continuing with punishment has a pretty predictable outcome: a child who continues to lack the skills to connect and manage their emotions; a child who is missing guidance on what respectful actions he can use to replace his instinctive actions; and a child who has diminishing self-esteem because of their internalized shame that they can’t meet their parent’s expectations and assuming the given label of “the bad kid”. 

Not where you thought you were going with time-outs, right?

A More Effective Approach

Emotion Coaching and Connection
And then there’s this alternative approach: emotion coaching. This method involves helping Max identify and articulate his feelings, like saying, “I see you’re upset because Lily took your toy.” It’s about providing him with alternative ways to express his emotions – “It’s okay to feel angry, but pushing isn’t safe. Next time, try telling us how you feel or asking for help.” This strategy focuses on the behavior, not the character, helping Max learn healthier ways to respond. The key is to impart these lessons not in the heat of the moment but during times of calm connection, when Max feels secure and valued.

What's next?

Our private Facebook group is a great resource for parents so you can find ease and joy in parenting while raising your toddler more intentionally and effectively. It’s a safe space to ask your questions about toddlerhood and to get answers to the millions of questions that come with the role of a parent. Join us and start enjoying parenthood more!

About Us

We are driven to help raise authentic humans. Come find out why.

Dig Deeper